Alright folks, it’s that time of year again! I originally planned on blogging a bit about the Hollywood and Top 24 weeks, but found myself to be rather uninspired. However, I’m back in the game and ready to dissect the Top 12 week after week. Before I recap the night, here is my prediction for each week’s cast-off!(note: not necessarily how I want it to happen, just how I think it will).
12. Lacy Brown
11. Tim Urban
10. Aaron Kelly
9. Paige Miles
8. Andrew Garcia
7. Michael Lynche
6. Katie Stevens
5. Didi Benami
4. Lee Dewyze
3. Casey James
2. Siobhan Magnus
1. Crystal Bowersox (winner)
Theme: Rolling Stones
Initial Thoughts: Don’t get me wrong, I love the Rolling Stones. Iconic band with amazing songs. However, I’m a little worried about tonight’s episode being completely boring. I’m not sure why, just a feeling. I think this is going to be a hard theme for certain contests to master. I digress…
Michael Lynche Miss You – I love this guy and I love his voice, but he HAS to stop dancing. When he’s stationary and working the microphone he’s kind of sexy. But when he’s dancing around on stage he looks like the State Puff Marshmallow Man! Regardless, I think he’s got mad skillz and a cute baby. An above average performance but nothing I was wowed by. Score = 7
Didi Benami Play With Fire – I really thought this was incredible. I really think she seems more comfortable on stage now and totally believable. I know some people can’t stand her, but I think she’s THE BALM! Score = 8
Casey James All Over Now – Ok. Sigh. I’m so not on the Casey James wagon. Or should I say, I’m not all over his jock like Kara. I think he’s reasonably talented but really not that great. I wonder how comfortable he’d be with the guitar? I felt like this was a very safe choice for him and at times the vocals were pretty weak. It wasn’t horrible, but meh. Score = 5
Lacy Brown Ruby Tuesday – This chick is getting so old to me. I never really loved her, but everything she does sounds the same! There wasn’t a ton of melody to the arrangement, so she couldn’t show much off. There is nothing wrong with her vocals, I just got very bored with this and am getting increasingly bored with her. Score = 4
Andrew Garcia Gimmie Shelter – I think he was a few notes away from having a really fantastic performance. There was something weird when he was singing “war children” and I’m thinking he might have been off-key briefly. It didn’t seem to work with the backup vocals. Regardless, I really enjoy him and think it was a decent performance. Great in spots, not so great in others. I hope he sticks around. Score = 6
Katie Stevens Wild Horses – This was pretty nice. That’s really all i have to say. At times it was sleepy and boring, but overall it was alright. She doesn’t inspire or excite me, but she’s a very talented singer. Score = 7.
Tim Urban Under My Thumb - I do have to give him some props for doing something a bit different with the song. However, it was pretty average. He doesn’t have a commanding voice and he knows this, which is why I commend him for doing something that will show off his talents. However, I think that’s only going to last him a little while before he gets sung right off the stage by the powerhouses. Is tonight is night to go? Score = 5
Siobhan Magnus Paint It Black - Wow. Love it or hate it, this girl has pipes. I’m actually a big fan. I don’t want her to do Screamy McScream every week, but it’s nice to hear what she’s got. She still makes weird faces when she sings, but I can get over that I suppose. Can you? Score = 9
Lee Dewyze Beast of Burden - I can’t help but love him. He’s personable, cute and has an amazing voice. I love his tone. He’s also got some Chicago connections, so I’m rooting for my boy! I really think he’s improved the most out of anyone. He’s a bit more confident and commanding and I really hope he stays around a while. I also have a mad crush on him. Score = 8
Paige Miles Honky Tonk – I really enjoy her and want her to do well. I liked the song choice a lot better than past choices. Had her voice been 100% I think she would have nailed this one. All things considered, she was pretty tight. Go Paige. Score = 7
Aaron Kelly Angie - So it really wasn’t terrible, but I feel like people like him more than they should. I didn’t think it was anything spectacular. However, he’s young and inexperienced and will probably get better. I don’t want to hate him, but I found this performance a bit sleepy and boring. I dunno. He is a cutie though, and quite endearing, so I can understand why no one wants to dog him. Score = 6
Crystal Bowersox You Can’t Always Get What You Want – I still think she’s the front-runner, but I’d agree with Simon: She totally lost the night to Siobhan. That being said, I’m pretty sure she’ll be around until the end. I’m predicting her to win it all. Great song choice, pretty nice delivery, but nothing crazy good about it. It was pretty safe and predictable in a lot of ways. Still, I love her. Score = 8
Bottom Three Prediction: I’m going to go with Lacy Brown, Tim Urban and Katie Stevens for the bottom. I’m guessing Lacy will go home, but perhaps someone like Tim Urban as well. When there are 12, anything can happen as the votes are saturated. Look for perhaps a surprise castaway like Andrew Garcia or Michael Lynche who might have been swept under the rug by the girls.